Damien Soitout
People buy a feeling when the news is loud. Sell the calm of a real product. Do not shout the headline, and do not go silent.
The street is loud. The window is selling something quieter.
People still buy a feeling when the news is loud. The window in the picture is lit. The street outside is brighter, strung with lights that are not about the shop. That is a loud season at the scale of one pavement, and it is the scale I want on 11 September 2023. Headlines are doing what headlines do. They fill the day. A seller who hears them has two bad reflexes. One is to shout over the news, to pin the product to the latest fear or the latest grief and call the pinning relevance. The other is to go silent and call the silence humility. Humility would be telling the truth about what you sell. Silence is a closed window. The customer on the pavement still needs the thing, or still wants the feeling the thing carries, and the news did not cancel the want. It only made the want harder to hear. Your job is to keep the feeling specific and the product real.
Customers buy emotions, not only the product is the older claim, and it survives a loud month. People buy relief, status, care, belonging, competence, a moment of calm. The product is the carrier. If you describe only the carrier, in specifications, you leave the feeling for the customer to invent, and in a loud week they will invent it out of the headline. If you describe only the feeling, with no fact underneath, you are selling fog. Fog is what shouting over the news produces. A quiet product has both: a fact a stranger can check, and a feeling that fact honestly supports.
Name the feeling in one sentence you would still say if the headlines went quiet tomorrow. “This is a tool that lets a small team finish the week without a chase.” “This is a drink you serve cold, before a meal, from a place with a rule.” “This is a service that answers the phone.” Test the sentence by deleting every word that only works because the news is loud. If nothing remains, you were newsjacking. What newsjacking is is the technique of attaching your offer to a story already in motion. Used with a light hand, on a story that truly touches the product, it can be a service: you show up where the question already is. Used because you are afraid of being unheard, it borrows pain. Borrowed pain is noticeable. Customers feel the borrow even when they cannot quote it. They buy somewhere else, from a window that did not dress itself in their fear.
Negativity is contagious inside a firm as well as outside it. A week of headlines can become the tone of the shop. Staff start apologizing for selling. They add a clause of gloom to every offer, as if the gloom proved they were serious people. Seriousness is the quality of the product and the clarity of the price. Gloom is a mood you caught. Turning customers into people who stay happens when the feeling they bought is the feeling they receive a second time. A fan is a repeat of a true experience. A fan is not someone you recruited with a slogan about the state of the world. Choosing a mentor helps here if the mentor has sold through a loud year and did not become either a commentator or a ghost. Ask them what they kept saying about the product when they were tempted to say something about the news. That sentence is the asset. Write it down. Put it on the window, in the message, in the way the phone is answered. Leave the headline on the street, where it already has enough light.
The feeling is not a substitute for the business. The World Bank's page on SME finance describes small and medium firms as the backbone of most economies, around 90 percent of businesses and more than half of global employment. It also describes a finance gap, in the trillions of dollars across emerging market and developing economies, and the ordinary trouble a small firm has in getting the money to start, continue, and grow. I cite that scale so a loud week does not convince a small seller that their size is a moral failure. Most firms are small. The employment is real. The gap is real. None of it is cured by a caption. A feeling can bring a customer to the window. A firm still needs a price that covers the cost, a way to get paid, and a plan for the week the customer does not come. Going silent does not close the gap. Shouting a headline does not close it either.
The U.S. Small Business Administration's guide to planning a business asks you to do the unglamorous work before the feeling gets all the attention. Market research asks whether people want the offer, how many, where they are, and what they already pay. A value proposition is a clear statement of the particular value you bring. Customer segments are specific, because you do not serve everybody. Channels are the ways you actually reach them. A lean plan can be one page. A traditional plan is longer when a lender asks. In a loud season I would rather see the one page than a manifesto. The page has the feeling in one line and the facts in the others: who it is for, what it costs you to deliver, what you charge, how they hear about it. If the news changed any of those facts, change the page. If the news only changed your mood, leave the page alone and change the mood.
A public example of a quiet product, with the feeling and the facts in the same place, is the FAQ for Floc de Gascogne. It is an aperitif. You serve it cold, between 5 and 7 degrees. It is one third young Armagnac and two thirds grape juice, between 16 and 18 degrees of alcohol, made on a named vineyard across part of the Gers, the Landes, and Lot-et-Garonne. The page gives a price band, generally 10 to 15 euros, and says where to buy it. The feeling is a place and a pause before a meal. The facts are a ratio, a map, and a rule. The page does not need a world headline to be intelligible. A local product week is still the news at that scale. In a louder week the same page is still the right way to sell: the feeling of a specific drink, not a comment on whatever the street is shouting. I use it as a model any seller can copy in structure. Your product is different. Your page should be as willing to be specific, and as unwilling to borrow the news.
Write three sentences and delete two kinds of words. The first sentence is the feeling, the one that would survive a quiet month. The second is the fact that makes the feeling honest: the material, the time, the place, the result the customer can check. The third is the price, or the way the price is set, so the feeling is not a trick. Then read the week's draft of your messages and remove every line whose only job is to prove you saw the headline. Remove, also, the apology for existing. A customer in a loud season is already carrying enough gloom. They did not come to the window to be told the world is heavy. They came because some corner of the week can still be light, useful, or well made. Give them that corner. Ready.gov's business page is about a different loudness, hazards that stop operations: storms, illness, outages, violence. The plan it asks for is written before the hazard, so the firm can continue. A news season is not a hurricane. The instinct matches. Decide in advance what you will keep selling, and how you will speak, so the week's headlines do not write your voice for you.
Staff need the same three sentences. If they invent a new feeling at every shift, the shop sounds nervous. Nervousness is contagious in both directions, from the street into the shop and from the shop back onto the street. Give them the sentences. Let them answer a customer who brings up the news as a person, not as a billboard. “Yes, it is a heavy week. Here is what we make. Here is what it costs.” That answer is respect. A speech is not respect. A silence that pretends the product is ashamed of itself is not respect either.
People buy a feeling when the news is loud, and they buy it from the seller who did not counterfeit the news. Keep the window lit. Keep the product the size it is. Say the feeling in words you can still use when the street is dark and ordinary. The ordinary week is when you find out whether the feeling was true. If it was true in the noise, it will still be true in the quiet, and the customers who stay will be the ones who bought the product, not the ones who bought your commentary. Commentary ages by Friday. A well-made thing, sold without costume, is still there on Monday.